I really don't know. I will predict anything from 60 to 75 for the time being since I'm expecting some people to really rip this video game apart for silly reasons. There are probably gamers and reviewers out there with unreasonable (unrealistic?) expectations who have already made up their minds to either like or dislike this video game. There are also probably gamers and reviewers out there who haven't played a decent survival horror video game in years and either don't know or don't remember what these video games are actually like.
I hope The Evil Within receives some fair reviews. I always hear about people praising its art direction and I know from my hands-on experience with this video game at E3 2014 that it looks pretty decent and has an incredibly fitting atmosphere. If its storyline is half as good as its art direction then, in my honest opinion, people shouldn't be giving it incredibly poor scores. I guess we will see what happens though.